Military Windows Xp Software Discount Buy Photoshop Com Mac Purchase Autodesk Autocad Electrical 2012 Cheap Buy Microsoft Office Visio 2012 Windows 8 Serial Key Consumer Preview Buy Windows Xp Media Center Edition 2005 Adobe Photoshop Cs6 Vs Extended Download Windows 8 Xtreme 32 Bit Buy Adobe Photoshop Cs6 Rosettastone Irish Level 1 Mac Buy Microsoft Mouse India Download Windows 7 Enterprise Iso Buy Low Price Oem Autodesk Autocad 2009 Online Microsoft Office 2013 Purchase Microsoft Office 2013 License Windows 7 Starter Can I Buy Windows 7 Starter Edition Windows 7 Singapore Buy Windows 7 Online Singapore Get Discounted Oem Microsoft Windows Vista Business Online Microsoft Office Access 2010 Access 2010 Price Microsoft Office Visio 2003 Purchase 2003 Visio Autocad 2011 Oem Get Oem Microsoft Mappoint Europe 2009 Cheap Adobe Incopy Cs55 Oem Where Can You Buy A Windows Vista Restore Disk Buy Microsoft Frontpage Office 2004 Student And Teacher Edition Mac Voip Cheap Windows 7 Best Price Photoshop Cs5 Purchase Adobe Premiere Cs5 Proall Buy Windows 7 Key Cheap Why Buy Windows 7 Ultimate Windows 7 Keygen Zip Office 2007 Ultimate Buy Cheap Download Cheap Quicken Rental Property Manager 2011 Oem Windows 8 Activation Key Txt Download Download Windows 8 Media Player Cheap Autodesk Autocad Revit Structure Suite 2012 Oem Microsoft Windows 8 Build 8400 Buy Windows 8 30 Euro Best Buy Windows 7 1199 Cheap Oem Software Best Downloads Windows Xp Windows Downloads For Xp Buy Microsoft Office Teacher Windows 7 Keygen Cheap Outlook Cheap Creative Suite 5 Master Collection Mac Oem Buy Windows Xp Professional Purchase Adobe Buy Cs4 Web Premium Graphisoft Archicad 15 Mac Buy Discounted Oem Adobe Photoshop Cs6 9 Cheapest Adobe Cs6 Master Adobe Creative Suite 6 Master Collection English For Mac Buy Windows Kinect Buy Creative Suite 5 Production Premium Cheap Windows 8 Keynote Best Price Adobe Illustrator Eset Smart Security 4 (32-bit) Buy Powercinema 6 Windows 8 Consumer Edition Key Windows 7 Professional Price Of Windows 7 Professional Malaysia Get Windows 7 Cheap Microsoft Expression Studio 4 Ultimate Cheap Maya Software Get Low Price Rosetta Stone Version 3 Arabic All Levels Set For Mac Online Cheapest Place Buy Windows 7 Professional Buy Cs5 Or Wait For Cs 6 Microsoft Visual Studio 2008 Professional Buy Windows 7 Digital Download Microsoft Windows 8 32bit Download Oem Windows 8 8306 Download Where To Buy Windows Vista Online Buybelightsoftwareliveinterior3dproeditionmacoem Best Price Dtsearch Uk Desktop 766 Windows 7 Oem Vs Windows 7 Upgrade Buy BurnAware Professional oem Daz Carrara 8 Pro Mac Microsoft Spain Windows Downloads Get Now Cheap Microsoft Office Mac Uk Adobe Creative Suite 4 Design Premium Microsoft Windows Web Server 2008 R2 (64 Bit) Buy With Best Price Autodesk Simulation Mechanical 2012 Discount Oem Microsoft Office Project Professional 2007 Sp2 Cheap Microsoft Works 90 Oem Where To Buy Windows Xp Yahoo Answers Price Adobe Indesign Adobe After Effects Cs6 For Mac Oem Buy Incopy Cs55 Cheap Lightroom 4 Price Innovative Solutions Advanced Uninstaller Pro 9.5 Windows 7 Oem Mac Bootcamp Cheap Autodesk Software Purchase Adobe Cs5 Master Collection Buy Windows 7 Key Windows 7 Home Premium Vs Professional Buy Windows 7 Edu Windows 7 Oem Recovery Partition Group Buy Software Cheap Windows 7 Compatible Sound Card Boris Graffiti 5.2 Download Windows 7 Japanese Language Pack Cheap Microsoft Office 2007 Ultimate Oem Adobe Creative Suite 6 Master Collection Serial Codes Cheap Microsoft Windows Xp 2012 Live Usb Edition Oem Buy Microsoft Office Government Cs5 Oem Download Windows 7 Ultimate (64 Bit) Just Want Buy Microsoft Word Buy Windows 7 Bulk Cheap Showcases Buy Windows 7 Cheap Students Download Windows 7 64 Bit Home Premium Microsoft Windows 8 For Mac Buy Windows 7 Oem Online Buy Windows Xp With Sp2 Microsoft Windows 8 64bit Where To Buy Buy Windows 7 50 Diferencia Windows 7 Oem Y Box Buy Download Software Price Server 2003 Autodesk 3ds Max 2012 Corel Video Studio Pro X2 Cheap Photoshop Upgrade Cheap Windows 7 Mobile Buy Computer With Windows 7 Professional Buy Cs 55 Design Premium Cheap Buy Photoshop Cs6 Extended Mac Download Windows 8 Release Preview Iso Cheap Windows 7 Bootcamp Microsoft Office Publisher 2003 Download Windows 7 Anytime Upgrade Buying 2007 Microsoft Office Windows 7 Professional 64 Price Of Windows 7 Professional 64 Bit Adobe Elements Best Price Buy Windows 8 India Cheap Microsoft Office For Nhs Staff Purchase Full Oem Version Win8 32 Buy Adobe Cs5 Design Online Office 2003 Professional Sp3 Purchase Oem Buy Windows 7 Home Premium Mac Microsoft Windows 8 Tablet Surface Buy Microsoft Office India Online Buy Microsoft Office Visio Microsoft Streets Trips 2011 College Students Buy Windows 7 Home Vs Professional Buy Microsoft Points Cheap Buy Microsoft Office Canada Best Price Microsoft Office 2012 Portable Price Adobe Flash Windows 7 Oem O Que Significa Buy Archicad 12 Buy Microsoft Office 2010 Can Buy Windows 8 Tablet Purchase Oem Software Online Windows Server 2008 R2 Datacenter (64 Bit) How To Buy Windows 7 Ultimate Windows Downloads Cursors Purchase Mcafee Device Control 90 Cheap Acronis True Image Home 2011 Oem Cheap Photoshop Cs5 Oem Download Windows 8 Setup File Buy Cyberlink Youcam 3 Cheap Cheap Windows 7 2012 Buy Cheap Adobe Cs5 Master Autodesk Simulation Multiphysics 2012 Purchase Norton Ghost 150all Buy Microsoft Office Word Adobe Creative Suite 6 Master Collection Amtlib.dll Buy Adobe Creative Suite Cs5 Design Standard Buy Windows 7 Oem Online Cheap Ventura 10 Creative Suite 5 Cheap Price Installshield X Express Edition Buy Windows 7 To Download Cheap Windows 8.1 Keys Office 2004 Student And Teacher Edition Mac Download Software For Cheap Adobe Creative Suite 6 Master Collection Cheap Price Purchase Microsoft Office 2007 Purchase Mcafee Epolicy Orchestrator 45 Buy Cheap Windows 7 Os Windows 7 Student Discount For High School Excel 2003 Sale Windows 8 32 Bit Cost Canada Oem Serial Number Microsoft Visual Studio 2008 Professional Macrabbit Cssedit 2 Mac Buy Windows 8 Laptop Windows 7 Key Extract Windows 7 Home Premium Join Domain Hack Cheap Zonealarm Internet Security Suite 70 Oem Buy Oem Software Online Microsoft Visual Studio Team Foundation Server 2010 Adobe Acrobat 9 Pro Mac Best Buy Adobe Photoshop Cs6 Best Price Ahead Nero Burning Rom 10 Cheap Windows 8 Upgrade Buy Photoshop World Mac Stargosoft Password Saver Buy Microsoft Zune India Microsoft Office Buying Ms Office Buy Photoshop Elements Uk Mac Download Windows 8 For Xp Buy Windows Xp Purchase Premiere Cs5 Buyautodesksoftimage2011oem Buy Windows 7 Upgrade From Vista Adobe Incopy Cs5 For Mac Student And Teacher Edition Oem Buy Autocad Architecture 2008 Cheap Microsoft Office Access 2007 Autodesk Motionbuilder 2011 Buying Windows 7 Starter Windows 7 Home Premium Oem Buy Photoshop Beginners Photoshop Cs6 Price Uk Purchase Microsoft System Center Operations Manager 2007 R2 Cheap Autodesk Simulation Multiphysics 2012 Oem Microsoft Office Excel 2010 (64-bit) Cheap Windows 7 64 Bit Oem Windows 8 Student Discount For High School Windows 7 Oem Disc Cheap Mcafee Total Protection 2012 Oem Best Prices On Creative Suite 6 Production Premium Windows 7 Professional 32 Bit 64 Bit Dual-hotload Os Brainjuice Blogo Mac Buy Adobe Acrobat Cheapest Buy Windows 7 Enterprise Online Microsoft Windows 8 Iso Autodesk Inventor Publisher 2012 (64-bit) Windows 8 Best Price Buyborisfx10(64-bit)oem Microsoft Office 2012 Professional (32-bit) Best Price On
Is the shale gas boom a bubble? | KEYE Austin - Green Right Now Austin News, Weather, Traffic KEYE-TV Austin - HOME

Is the shale gas boom a bubble?

 Posted by on February 20, 2013
Feb 202013

From Green Right Now Reports

The U.S. shale boom, being touted as able to deliver 100 years of domestic energy supply, is nothing more than the latest investment bubble, asserts a report released this week by a veteran geologist.

Drill Baby Drill ReportJ. David Hughes, a Canadian who served for 32 years with the Geological Survey of Canada, says the inflated expectations for natural gas and “tight oil” in boom areas far outpace the reality of what can be accessed and reasonably extracted.

His report , Drill, Baby, Drill, was released by the Post Carbon Institute where Hughes is a fellow. It refers to the fracking of natural gas across the US in active drilling regions such as the Marcellus and Barnett shale formations, in the Northeast and Texas, respectively, and also the Bakken and Eagle Ford oil fields, where hundreds of wells are being drilled in a latter-day oil boom that’s raised hopes for domestic oil producers and consumers.

Fracking Follies

These regional boom areas have  ’allowed previously inaccessible shale gas and tight oil to reverse the long-standing decline of U.S. oil and gas production,” Hughes concedes in the summary of his findings. “This production growth is important and has provided some breathing room.”

“Nevertheless, the projections by pundits and some government agencies that these technologies can provide endless growth heralding a new era of “energy independence,” in which the U.S. will become a substantial net exporter of energy, are entirely unwarranted based on the fundamentals. At the end of the day fossil fuels are finite and these exuberant forecasts will prove to be extremely difficult or impossible to achieve.”

These “fracked” wells are rapidly depleted and the area of exploration also quickly reaches a point at which the expenditure of time and effort to extract more gas or oil reaches a point that no longer makes economic sense, his report concludes.

“Wells experience severe rates of depletion, belying industry claims that wells will be in operation for 30-40 years,” the report notes.

Shale Map from Drill Baby Drill

You can use this map at the Drill, Baby, Drill report to see information about individual shale gas and oil wells near you.

As evidence, the report offers an interactive map of the natural gas and “tight oil” boom regions in which the data for 63,000 individual wells and the exploration region can be seen. The graphic reveals that the fuel being drawn from these wells tapers off quickly, supporting Hughes’ thesis that there’s not as much natural gas available as industry and investment boosters would have the public believe.

So many wells are required to keep production high, the economics or fundamentals can erode as quickly as the natural gas supply, he reports.

The Wall Street Factor

So who benefits? Wall Street investors and traders have made money on the upswing in natural gas production and then on the backside, on mergers and acquisitions, as the companies consolidate in an effort to keep going.

More on this angle is available in another report released this week by the Energy Policy Forum. Was the Decline in Shale Gas Prices Orchestrated by Wall Street?, a report by financial consultant Deborah Rogers, argues that the boom and decline in natural gas has been an engine for trading profits, but the benefits of the gas boom will bypass the wider U.S. population.

Key points from Rogers’ report:

  • Wall Street promoted the shale gas drilling frenzy, which resulted in prices lower than the cost of production and thereby profited [enormously] from mergers & acquisitions and other transactional fees.
  • U.S. shale gas and shale oil reserves have been overestimated by a minimum of 100% and by as much as 400-500% by operators according to actual well production data filed in various states
Rogers, who has spent 30 years in financial circles and served on the advisory council for the Dallas Federal Reserve Board, says that natural gas companies are understandably turning to exportation to get better prices for their output. That could turn the US into an energy exporter, but it belies the marketing hype that natural gas will boost domestic supplies and make the US energy independent. From her report:
Beginning in 2009, the number of M&A deals within the shale market began to explode. Initially, many transactions involved foreign investors such as Chinese, Korean, French and Norwegian companies looking to purchase U.S. shale assets. The banks effected these transactions for large fees.
Natural Gas Industry Map

The natural gas industry touts the longevity of natural gas supplies and the jobs they support.

Rogers view aligns with Hughes’, in that both argue that the natural gas industry should be better scrutinized, and soon, because it will be US citizens who bear the pollution burden, and not necessarily receive the benefits (albeit smaller than predicted) of unconventional natural gas extraction.

Back to Hughes’ assessment, there is no shortage of people who disagree with him. America’s Natural Gas Alliance (ANGA) promises to “power America for generations to come” and proffers a different interactive map — this one showing the thousands of jobs and estimated economic benefits related to gas drilling.

Hughes’ report itself cites a sampling of the rosy predictions for natural gas made by financial and energy analysts, but only to show the extent of what he considers a mythology of fossil fuel abundance. This storyline is often recited  by Washington leaders, including President Barack Obama, who is quoted in Drill, Baby, Drill as mimicking the marketing line:

We have a supply of natural gas that can last America nearly 100 years, and my administration will take every possible action to safely develop this energy.

Hughes isn’t the first person to question the natural gas boom. But his report, nine months in the making, delves into some details that may not be widely understood.

A key point in his analysis is that fracked wells produce a burst of natural gas, followed by a steep drop off in production. This is an acknowledged phenomenon of hydrofracturing, in which gas formations inaccessible to conventional vertical drilling are blasted open along a horizontally bored well, using high pressure fluids containing water, sand, lubricants and other ingredients. It’s the reason that “fracking” requires multiple wells be drilled from eqach pad site.

Horizontal fracturing or “fracking” is by design more intensive than conventional drilling.

But Hughes maintains that the ramifications of that, the extra toll on the environment as well as the underlying economics, should play a more prominent role in the public discourse.

The public has been getting an education in hydrofracturing or “fracking” as drillers have expanded into the countryside and even into cities, like Fort Worth and Dallas. The extensive drilling, potential migration of toxic fluids, heavy dependence on water (a well can require two to five million gallons of water) and problematic disposal of fracking fluids are among the reasons dozens of citizens’ groups opposing “fracking” have sprung up in Colorado and Texas to Ohio, Pennsylvania and New York.

The debate has often centered on environmental risks, with activists arguing that the pollution of the gas industry jeopardizes water and air quality in nearby communities.

Hughes says the economic risks of relying on natural gas need more exploration as well, because the U.S. is risking future energy and economic security by counting on a fossil fuel abundance that could be, at least in part, a marketing mirage.

“Constraints in energy supply are certain to strain future international relations in unpredictable ways and threaten U.S. and global economic and political stability,” he writes. “The sooner the real problems are recognized by political leaders, the sooner real solutions to our long term energy problem can be implemented.”

( J. David Hughes served as Team Leader for Unconventional Gas on the Canadian Gas Potential Committee, where he coordinated the recent publication of a comprehensive assessment of Canada’s unconventional natural gas potential. He has researched and lectured on global energy and sustainability issues in North America and around the globe. He is a board member of the Association for the Study of Peak Oil and Gas – Canada and is a Fellow of the Post Carbon Institute, according to his biographical sketch published in the report.)